Dental Waterline Outbreaks: Case Studies, Risks, and How to Protect Your Practice 

Written By Eric Deas

Dental unit waterlines (DUWLs) have been linked to a range of  serious infection-control failures in dentistry—most notably pediatric outbreaks caused by nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM). These events underscore a critical truth: waterline safety isn’t optional. For every clinic, the path to prevention is clear—consistent waterline treatment, routine verification testing, and documented remediation. Without these measures, even well-intentioned practices can become the next headline. 

Understanding these events—and the risks of neglecting waterline maintenance—is essential for patient safety and regulatory compliance. Offices with a commitment to waterline safety demonstrate a commitment to their patients and the highest standards of care.

Dental Waterline Safety Is Non-Negotiable 

The Hidden Risk in Every Operatory 

Dental waterlines are designed for convenience, but their structure creates an ideal environment for microbial growth. Narrow tubing, intermittent water flow, and periods of stagnation allow biofilm to form quickly. Once established, biofilm becomes a reservoir for pathogens that can contaminate water used in patient care. These contaminants may be introduced directly via the dental water and even breathed in as the water is aerosolized. Even water that looks clear can exceed safe microbial limits by thousands of CFU/mL. This invisible danger is why routine monitoring and treatment is critical and not just recommended. 

Case Studies: When Waterline Neglect Turns Into Health Impacts

Georgia (2024) 

  • Impact: Pediatric patient developed Mycobacterium abscessus infection after pulpotomy. 

  • Cause: High bacterial counts in dental water; no routine waterline treatment or monitoring. 

  • Outcome: Negative impact on office reputation and significant legal exposure. 

France (2024)

  • Impact: Persistent DUWL contamination even after initial shock disinfection in new dental chairs.

  • Cause: Biofilm resilience; inadequate initial treatment protocols; Pseudomonas aeruginosa detected post-disinfection.

  • Outcome: No clinical infections reported, but findings underscore risk of biofilm persistence and need for ongoing monitoring and maintenance.

CDC Advisory (2022) 

  • The CDC issued a Health Alert Network (HAN) warning after multiple clusters of NTM infections tied to pediatric dental clinics. 

Key recommendations: 

  • Maintain DUWL water at ≤500 CFU/mL heterotrophic bacteria 

  • Use sterile water or saline for surgical procedures 

  • Implement routine monitoring and documentation

Venezuela (2020)

  • Impact: Three severe odontogenic infections in pediatric patients linked to DUWL contamination.

  • Cause: High bacterial counts in DUWLs (up to 1,000 CFU/mL); presence of NTM and Pseudomonas; lack of documented waterline treatment and monitoring.

  • Outcome: Clinical infections requiring extensive treatment; highlighted systemic gaps in infection control across multiple clinics.

Ecuador (2020)

  • Impact: No reported infections, but widespread DUWL contamination detected in 73% of sampled units.

  • Cause: Poor waterline maintenance; high levels of heterotrophic bacteria, coliforms, and occasional NTM presence.

  • Outcome: Elevated risk for patient infection; prompted recommendations for routine monitoring and disinfection protocols.

California (2016)

  • Impact: 71 pediatric patients developed NTM infections after pulpotomies.  More than 200 lawsuits with an estimated cost of tens of millions.

  • Cause: Extremely high bacterial counts in DUWLs; no routine waterline monitoring. 

  • Outcome: Hospitalizations, surgeries, permanent tooth loss, and facial nerve damage.

Georgia (2015) 

  • Impact: Dozens of children infected with NTM following dental procedures. 

  • Cause: Clinics lacked documented waterline protocols and testing. 

  • Outcome: Hospitalizations and surgeries. Extensive remediation and legal exposure for affected practices. 

Health Risks Tied to Dental Water 

 

Why DUWLs Are High-Risk 

  • Biofilm Formation: Narrow tubing, low flow, and stagnation create ideal conditions for biofilm. 

  • Pathogens of Concern: Legionella, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and NTM among others can thrive in untreated lines. 

  • Invisible Danger: Water can look clear yet exceed safe microbial limits by thousands of CFU/mL. 

Risks of Not Testing or Treating 

  • Patient Harm: Severe infections, hospitalizations, and permanent complications. 

  • Staff Exposure: Aerosols generated during procedures can carry bacteria, posing a risk to dental staff and patients

  • Regulatory Infractions: 40 states have codified waterline treatment and monitoring into their Dental Board and others have implemented additional state-specific mandates for testing and documentation (e.g., Georgia, Washington).

  • Reputation Damage: Media coverage and lawsuits following outbreaks. 

  • Financial Impact: Litigation costs and operational disruption far exceed prevention costs. 

Obtaining Complete Waterline Safety 

Prevention: The Proven Protocol 

  • Shock: Remove biofilm with more aggressive disinfectants before first use and as needed. 

  • Treat: Apply continuous or intermittent treatment to control bacteria and prevent biofilm regrowth. 

  • Test: Verify water quality regularly. Start with monthly testing until consistent passes are obtained, then move to quarterly; document all results. 

(Check local/state regulations for specific requirements.) 

Implementation Plan 

  1. Write or update your DUWL standard operating procedure (SOP) and conduct training.

    • Identify shock, treatment, and testing products & review IFUs

    • Include treatment and testing frequencies

    • Specify remedial actions steps to take if a failure occurs

  2. Shock all lines upon initial startup, after maintenance, and after boil advisories.

  3. Conduct baseline testing to confirm water quality. 

  4. Shock failures and retest 2-3 days later to verify remediation.

  5. Proceed with continuous maintenance treatment products.

  6. Monitor routinely and document results for compliance and safety. 

Agenics Labs makes dental waterline compliance simple. We provide expert guidance, testing solutions, and support for implementation to keep your practice safe and compliant. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and ensure your waterlines meet the highest standards of safety.

Eric Deas
Next

AAMI ST108: Redefining Water Quality Standards in Sterile Processing